When the Dust Settles: What Every Owner and Contractor Must Know About Warranties

When you build or renovate a property, you’re not just investing money—you’re investing trust. You trust that the contractor will do the job right, that materials will last, and that your new space will be safe, functional, and valuable for years to come. But construction is complex, and even with the best intentions, defects can and do occur. That’s where construction warranties step in. These legal protections don’t just spell out rights and responsibilities, they also act as a safety net for both owners and contractors. Understanding them is essential to protecting your property and avoiding unnecessary legal battles.

What Are Construction Warranties?

At their core, construction warranties are promises about the quality of work and materials provided on a project. They are not just paperwork or marketing language—they’re enforceable legal obligations that determine what happens if something goes wrong. Warranties typically fall into two categories:

Express warranties: These are written down, often in the construction contract. For example, a contractor might guarantee a roof for five years.

Implied warranties: These exist even if they aren’t explicitly mentioned. Courts often impose them to ensure a minimum level of quality, such as the implied warranty of habitability (that the property is livable) or the implied warranty of good workmanship (that the job was done to industry standards).

Without warranties, property owners would have very little recourse when defects appear, and contractors would face constant disputes without a framework for resolution.

How Long Do Construction Warranties Last?

One of the most common questions property owners ask is, “How long am I covered?” The answer depends on whether the warranty is express or implied, and on state law. In Florida, for example, express warranties last for whatever time the contract specifies, which could range from one year to a decade or more. Implied warranties last for a “reasonable time,” which courts usually interpret based on the nature of the work.

Additionally, legal deadlines apply:

• Florida’s statute of limitations gives owners four years from the time a defect is discovered to file a claim.
• The statute of repose creates a hard stop at ten years from project completion, no matter when the defect is found.

Knowing these deadlines is critical, because waiting too long could leave owners footing the repair bill—even if the defect was the contractor’s fault.

Common Defects Covered by Warranties

Not all problems count as warranty issues. Warranties generally focus on defects tied to the contractor’s work or materials, not on normal wear-and-tear or natural disasters. For example, if your roof leaks because it was installed incorrectly, that’s typically a warranty issue. But if it leaks 20 years later due to old age, that’s not. Covered defects often include:

• Structural flaws, such as foundation cracks or unstable framing.
• Water damage from faulty roofing, siding, or window installations.
• Mechanical system failures, like plumbing leaks or electrical hazards.
• Workmanship problems, including uneven flooring, poor finishing, or defective tile work.

By clarifying which issues are covered, warranties help both owners and contractors avoid endless arguments over responsibility.

Contractor Obligations Under Warranties

For contractors, warranties are more than a customer service gesture—they’re legal duties. Once a warranty is in place, contractors are bound to honor it, which means repairing or replacing defective work when valid claims arise. This also means contractors must:

• Perform work that meets building codes and professional standards.
• Accurately describe the warranties being offered—misrepresenting them could be considered fraud.
• Keep thorough records to prove that warranty obligations were met.
• Respond promptly to warranty claims instead of delaying or ignoring requests.

Failing to comply doesn’t just damage a contractor’s reputation—it can also lead to breach of contract lawsuits, negligence claims, or even liability for additional damages caused by the defect.

Owner Rights Under Warranties

For property owners, warranties are a powerful tool. They ensure that if a contractor fails to deliver as promised, there’s a legal path to make things right. Owners can typically seek:

• Repairs or replacement of defective work.
• Reimbursement for repair costs they had to cover themselves.
• Legal remedies, including filing a breach of warranty or contract lawsuit.

However, owners also have responsibilities. They must report defects in a timely manner, cooperate with repair efforts, and avoid interfering with contractors trying to fix problems. Ignoring these steps could weaken a claim or even void the warranty altogether.

Legal Remedies for Breach of Warranty

When contractors don’t honor warranties, owners have several legal tools at their disposal. The most common is a breach of contract lawsuit, which enforces express warranties written into the agreement. Owners can also bring claims for breach of implied warranties, especially when work fails to meet minimum standards of habitability or workmanship.

Florida law often requires a pre-suit notice process, such as under Chapter 558, which gives contractors the chance to inspect and repair defects before the case heads to court. This process can save time and money for both sides, but if repairs aren’t satisfactory, litigation may still follow.

Preventing Warranty Disputes

Warranty disputes can be stressful, expensive, and damaging to relationships. Fortunately, many are preventable with proactive steps:

• Contractors should use clear, attorney-reviewed contracts that outline warranty terms.
• Both parties should document everything, from inspection reports to text messages.
• Owners should report issues promptly instead of waiting until small problems become big ones.
• Maintaining open communication can help resolve issues early, before they escalate into litigation.

By building a strong paper trail and fostering trust, owners and contractors can reduce the chances of disputes turning into lawsuits.

Why It Matters

Construction warranty claims are not just technical legal issues—they’re the backbone of accountability in construction. For owners, they provide peace of mind and financial protection when defects appear. For contractors, they define obligations, build credibility, and help maintain long-term client relationships. Whether you’re building your dream home or managing large commercial projects, knowing how warranties work ensures that everyone involved has clear expectations and legal protections.

Got Defective Work? Don’t Let Warranty Disputes Drain Your Time and Money.

Construction defect and warranty claims can quickly turn into financial nightmares if not handled properly. Whether you’re a homeowner seeking to enforce your rights or a contractor defending your work, the right legal strategy makes all the difference.

• Call us at (239) 422-6400
• Email us at contact@dufaultlaw.com
• Or Visit our Contact Page to schedule a consultation